You decide to convince her otherwise with Philosophy!

Sarah is much more well read on the math, so you think you’ll have better luck convincing her with some philosophical arguments. What argument do you use?

Use the ship of Theseus argument, a Dini copy wouldn’t be the same hamster when you think about it.

You’re messing with the natural order of the world; this could have huge butterfly effect consequences

The world is already populated with people and hamsters, shouldn’t you just take care of a new hamster?

According to the tenants of Darwinism, Dini being murdered by the cat means we should let him die and not re-enter the gene pool.